My Tractor Forum banner

Deciding between a Cub Cadet and a Husqavarna

26K views 19 replies 14 participants last post by  FLHusqGT  
#1 ·
We are looking at getting either a Cub Cadet XT2 GX54 or a Husqavarna YTH24V54. We have a very flat 4.5 acres and eventually will want to get a full size tractor, but we will start off with one of these two. The Cub is being offered at 3899 and the Husq is on sale at Lowes for 2049.

Being that they are the same size I cant really justify the 1800 difference. Any reason to go with the Cub? I like the fact the Husq is a Swedish company over the cubs being made in China, but I am not an expert in terms of the companies background and the differences between these models.

Ok. Tell me what I should buy?
 
#2 ·
What you will be getting will be commensurate with what you pay...I am not partial to either one at all.....although the IH CCs were built to last forever...and you are not comparing apples to apples...that Husky is a Lawn Tractor...that Cub is a Garden Tractor...you NEED a garden tractor for a lot that sized...do a little more research to protect yourself...that Husk is not the same as the Cub.....the CC has a Tuff Torq 58...and a slightly larger engine ...not sure what the Husk has in it....the Husk does not list any ground engaging attachments...the CC does list a Snow blower ( 3 stage ) ..actually with a flat lot that size...also look into a Zero Turn...if your immediate need is just mowing and you do not really have any real tractor tasks that need attention until you get a "full size"...Zero Turn is a speedy alternative
 
#3 ·
Let me clarify one important point. We are looking to go with a Massey Ferguson GC1725 long term because of the true implements we want... right now the concern is mowing and totting around a small trailer to grab wood from the woods behind us for fires...

Long term we have a lot of plans but want to save for the MF. I agree a zero turn is better for speed. Right now not looking to break the bank for a garden tractor as you put it for sake of some attachments I may not need right now. I have a snowblower currently.

Final thoughts?
 
#4 ·
If the question is between the two mentioned above and ONLY the two mentioned above, I’d go with the cub, specifically for mowing that much. Unless you want to mow with the Massey in the future. In that case, go with the husq if you plan on a literal disposable machine for not a lot of up front cost, and save the cash.

Might be nice to still have the Cub in 10 years as a backup machine. The Cub will outlast the husqvarna with all things equal (use, maintenance, accidents).

If it were me in your shoes, I’d be 100% looking for a used garden tractor in good condition. I’m partial to Toro/Wheelhorse Classic stuff myself due to attachment interchangeability, quality, and low cost, but there are offerings from A LOT of other great brands out there.
 
#7 · (Edited)
jderosa3,

This is becoming fairly confusing IMO.

First you ask thoughts on two models, throw in another being the Massey and one more, the TS354D which I have no idea what brand that is.

Look at TractorData.com - information on all makes and models of tractors and you will be able to compare apples to oranges.

My own opinion, I would stay away from the Husqvarna because of frame issues which may have been corrected.

I second finding a used GT, might get more bang for your buck if someone else pays for the new shine!

CCMoe
 
#8 ·
Closer comparison...but the K66 in the Husq is not serviceable ,..the K58 in the Cub is the best in the residential line of Tuff Torq..and that 66 is going to have a tough time on a lawn that size over the long run....Husq is the largest manufacturer of OPE in the world...but it is not in the same league as the Cub....I agree with go used GT...even an older Husk or Craftsman over the new Husk
 
#9 ·
I once read on this Forum "buy once, cry once" . Last summer I found myself in the market for a new mower. I damaged my deck to the point that I couldn't get it to mow properly. I had a 10 yr old CC SLTX 1050 which I was very happy with. So I went to CC to replace it but the dealer was basically out of stock until this spring season so looked a Husqvarna and I found a lot of complaints online about them, from the under size Trans to the frames cracking. I went to the dealers to see the tractors. I would stay away from the big box stores. I finally went to a John Deere Dealer and I could see why they are $1000s more, they are built to last and do the jobs you need to do. I ended up getting a X738 with HC 54 auto connect. I didn't want to break the bank so opted for the 60 months 0% no money down, so it is painless.
I mowed my neighbors yard ( 4 acres } whose Kubota was still at the dealer on Monday and it took me 3 hours.
Just something to think about.
 
#10 ·
@jderosa3

I currently own the GX54 and briefly owned the previous model of the TS354. I would vote for the Cub Cadet, primarily because it’s a dealer model. The quality of ride of the XT2 is VASTLY superior to the Husqvarna. it’s also nice to know that the salesman will stand behind the product being sold, whereas Lowe’s will just forward your info to whatever “authorized repair center” is first in the list. The good thing about Lowe’s and Home Depot is that they will sell their left over stock at a huge discount at the end of the season.
 
#12 ·
Being someone who has owned a Husqvarna, I can say, mowing with the used GTH27V52LS was a great deal for mowing. I bought it to use at a widow’s house who couldn’t afford to replace her or her husband’s 42” Yardman. Both were old and his had a failed Kohler Courage engine. Mowing 3 acres was taking 6 hrs. With the the Husqvarna it was taking 1 1/2 hrs and gave a better cut. It’s on its 7th year. Not all “tractors” are the same, even from the same manufacturer. Get as heavy duty as you can afford with a serviceable transaxle, but I tend to hang on to my stuff for a long time and I buy once. I’ve not been impressed with the newer CC‘s as compared to older ones. Once you test drive some of the newer machines and some higher end units, you will quickly understand why they cost more. Things like power steering wouldn’t have been considered, but with use, you find it very helpful if not necessary as my friend did after having a shoulder replaced. Bigger machines ride smoother and are more stable on slopes/hills. Then there’s the hp needed to do the job without having to slow to a snail’s pace or maybe not at all. The first time you skid down a slope, you will understand the value of weight and types of tires.

If you are new to mowing, there’s a lot to learn and consider. Each situation is different. So my recommendation is try as many as you can, even if you feel you can’t afford it, but don’t discount one strictly based on the bad history of some others who just pushed their’s too far. Used gently, even the cheap stuff lasts quite a while and can be repaired. My example is my 2002 Scotts L17.542. I shouldn’t have expected it to still be going or be able to pull around my Cyclone Rake, but it did for several years even in my ditch in front of the house. Especially since all I’ve done is change oil & filer, change/sharpen blades, replace the battery a couple of times. I haven’t even changed the transaxle oil and it is still going after 300+ hours picking up a few leaves now and then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeitherFirstnorLast
#14 · (Edited)
My 2003 & 2019 Cubs were built here in the USA, not China. Granted they may use some castings from China such as the cast iron diff housing as is under my XT3 GS but you can be rest assured that diff housing is loaded with bullet proof hydro-gear BDU-10 internals. My 1st Cub was a 2166 and is now 17+ years old and needs it's first pto clutch; as soon as the dealer can pick it up that will be replaced. My XT3 GS was bought new last May and it is a hoss of a grass cutter that has cut my mowing time in half plus it's a stout material hauler. I cannot speak for the XT2 or XT1 but I have been well pleased with both of my Cubs. Good luck.
 
#17 · (Edited)
For 4.5 acres Your going to really be pushing a YTH24V54 with a K46 transmission the XT2 GX54 D will be a better machine But even 4.5 acres with that will be pushing it depending on what you plan to do with it until you get a Bigger tractor. Now Keep In Mind the Cub Also Has a excellent warranty compared to the Husqvarna You get 3 years Bumper to Bump and Unlimited Hours Plus Cub/MTD covers the Engine & Transmission Under there warranty While Husqvarna has You deal with the Engine & Transmission manufacturers separately from there supposedly Great warranty The Extra $1,800 will give You Piece of Mind. Your wallet In the Long run will thank You if You run into any issue with the Cub.

The Cub Has some components Made In China Just as Husqvarna Has. The Trans in the Cub Is Made In Tennessee By a Japanese owned company . The engine is Made In Mississippi Some electrical components Might be Made In China. But the Cub Is US Made In Ohio & Kentucky . The Cast Iron Transmission Case for the Cub Cadet XT3 Is Made in China They rest of the XT3 is US Made. I don't Know who told you Cub Is Made in China or even assembled In China. But they Honestly don't know what they are Talking about. Every outdoor Power equipment Manufacture On the Market today Has some components Made In China weather those components will still be Made In China after this year who Knows . But I doubt it (y)