you are going to get a lot of opinions on this one. I have no AG experience but do run chains.
No trouble what ever season it is.

No trouble what ever season it is.

i couldn't agree moreThis shouldn't be that hard of a decision. If you are working on hard ground, then the stock tires with chains will give you excellent bite and adding the wheel weights will increase that bite. However, if you are working in soft ground or muddy conditions, then the Ags win out because the large bars will penetrate and provide more traction than you will ever get from a chain.
Loading the Ags and/or adding wheel weights help increase the ability of the Ags to do their job.
But even the best Ags become useless if the tractor has no ground clearance when working in really soft ground. If the tractor hangs up on the ground beneath it, the tires will just spin no matter what tire, chains or weights you have on.
I don't find ag's any more of an issue on a lawn than a good set of chains. Both will tear up lawn here and there.The other thing to consider is whether or not you mow with this tractor? AG lugs will be detrimental to your lawn.
if you don't use it on a lawn, then I say go the cheep route for now, get the chains, load the tires with fluid, and if you need more, get the ag lugs.
Prior to our X500 arriving 1 month ago, for 24 years we cut our lawn with our old Ariens HT 16 GT with ags on it, never hurt our lawn.The other thing to consider is whether or not you mow with this tractor? AG lugs will be detrimental to your lawn.
if you don't use it on a lawn, then I say go the cheep route for now, get the chains, load the tires with fluid, and if you need more, get the ag lugs.
Chris, what box scraper did you buy and where did you find it in Mass?I bought the box scraper and took it out for a spin tonight. Just with the stock tires and no chains I was easily able to pull around piles of dirt that I piled up a year or so ago. It worked really well with little to no slipping. I will see how I do in the compost pile tomorrow.
Chris
Sears had a sale last weekend so I ordered the box scraper (Agri-Fab) and sleeve hitch from them. The scraper was $199 plus I got 8% bing cashback. I was using the box scraper this morning to move some dirt around and I am very impressed, it is pretty heavy duty.Chris, what box scraper did you buy and where did you find it in Mass?