Ive read through the Duraforce surging discussions and just some quick comment/logic on the butterfly vs jet issues;
Its assumed Toro/Lawnboy spec'd the butterfly plate with the smaller .055" dia. hole for the R-Tek (snowblower) carb, because LESS airflow is required during winter operation (cold air being more dense, containing more oxygen). Conversely, they spec'd the butterfly plate with the larger .100" dia. hole for the Duraforce mower carb, because MORE airflow is required during warmer summer operation (hot air being less dense, containing less oxygen).
Curiously, Toro/Lawnboy ALSO spec'd a larger 42.5 Pilot jet on the winter carb (R-Tek snowblower). Now this could be due to either the cold air containing so much more oxygen that the smaller air hole was still not enough to maintain proper air-fuel mixture ratio without surging at idle, or they ran a slightly richer mixture on the R-Tek due to the EPA's looser emission regulations on winter spec engines (relates to temperature -vs- atmospheric ozone depletion etc).
To point out the apples to oranges (R-Tek vs. Duraforce);
-The R-Tek is piston ported, Duraforce is Reed valve.
-The R-Tek is spec'd to run at 3800-4000 rpm, Duraforce 2900-3000 rpm.
-The R-Tek is spec'd at 50:1 gas;oil mix (richer mixture), Duraforce 32:1.
-The R-Tek pilot \ main jetting is 42.5 \ 73.8, Duraforce is 37.7 \ 77.5
The Duraforce mower engine should have the larger hole "summer" plate and be jetted accordingly. Using the smaller hole winter plate will starve the mower engine for oxygen in warmer weather causing a "rich-run" condition, unless it is "jetted down" to deliver less fuel as well. A check of the spark plug color will verify either way.
If you have "lean-run" surging (too much air, not enough fuel), then the order of business is 1) Make sure you have a correct and clean air filter in place 2) Check for vacuum leaks around gaskets, seals, air cleaner housing etc. 3) Make sure the inside of the carb is clean with no dust/dirt/debris clogging passages or jets 4) Try a larger pilot jet 5) Try a larger main jet.
My tinkerings with the Duraforce carb thus far have been limited, but apparently it shares the same pilot jet with the Suzuki 47P 2 cycle engine. Maybe someone can chime in if it also shares the same Main Jet design with the 47P as well. Here's some info on the 47P I've compiled; Carb info - so you can source jets anywhere, not just through mower $hops with Toro/LB/B&S pn's: Suzuki 47P 2 cycle, Mikuni B style butterfly carb, Mikuni part numbers;
Pilot jet (N101.043, 16mm long, 6.5mm head), available in increments of 2.5.
p/n: N101.043-37.5 (.375mm dia. holes), Pilot Jet #37.5 (LB "Duraforce")
p/n: N101.043-40 (.400mm dia. holes), Pilot Jet #40 (Toro "Suzuki 47P")
p/n: N101.043-42.5 (.425mm dia. holes), Pilot Jet #42.5 ("R-Tek", stock)
p/n: N101.043-45 (.450mm dia. holes), Pilot Jet #45 (Motorcycle shops)
p/n: N101.043-47.5 (.475mm dia. holes), Pilot Jet #47.5 (R-Tek high output)
Main jet (N102.221, 9mm long, 6mm head), available in increments of 2.5.
p/n: N102.221-75 (.750mm dia. hole), Main Jet #75 (Motorcycle shop)
p/n: N102.221-77.5 (.775mm dia. hole), Main Jet #77.5 (Toro 47P "High Alt")
p/n: N102.221-80 (.800mm dia. hole), Main Jet #80 (Toro 47P, stock)
p/n: N102.221-82.5 (.825mm dia. hole), Main Jet #82.5 (Motorcycle shop)
p/n: N102.221-85 (.850mm dia. hole), Main Jet #85 (Motorcycle shop)
One thing tinkerers discover quickly is the 2 cycle engine, for all its simplicity, is actually a finely tuned machine from top to bottom. This becomes apparent quickly when messing with air-fuel delivery systems engineered into designs by the factory, such as air cleaner housings, air filters, carbs, jets.