Yes RfWi, that is what I was thinking as well. If that spring, or clip, is opened up, or bent too large, and/or installed incorrectly it will mess things up for sure. Just remember that the open end will straddle the thin cast metal of the mag plate when installed correctly, and that is really what kicks the pinion gear into the flywheel. If that clip (spring) doesn't hold the pinion gear tight enough it will never move inboard and down the spiral pulley and fully engage the flywheel teeth...and it kinda needs to do that with authority, otherwise it will grind gears, or not engage at all.