I believe it is a 44" belt.
You should be using the large pulley. The small pulley is for a sickle mower. Be sure to release the PTO tension spring with the lever below the rear axle on the left side for installation then re-engage tension spring for operation.
Some references are here for belt part #:
http://www.tbs.dk/userfiles/Simplicity REM OG knivoversigt.pdf
and here to translate part number to size:
http://outdoorpowerinfo.com/belts/allis-chalmers_belts.asp
You should be using the large pulley. The small pulley is for a sickle mower. Be sure to release the PTO tension spring with the lever below the rear axle on the left side for installation then re-engage tension spring for operation.
Some references are here for belt part #:
http://www.tbs.dk/userfiles/Simplicity REM OG knivoversigt.pdf
and here to translate part number to size:
http://outdoorpowerinfo.com/belts/allis-chalmers_belts.asp