Richard,
Thank you for taking the time to share the more technical aspects of this with us. While not a difficult conversion, not something I would likley jump into since I don't have some of the resources you do.
Should my 16G, (18GLX ?) ever need an engine, I will likely go the new engine route. But actually I won't be unhappy if I never need to.
Reading this last night got me thinking more about the debated differences between the M18 supplied on my tractor, marked 16hp, and other M18's, GRAVELY or other wise.
I have a Kohler master parts list for the M18, M20 engines, and after even more review of the parts used on verious spec numbers, there is no doubt in my mind that the M18 on my 16G is every bit the same engine power wise as the same year 18G engine, and many other M18's installed on various other brands and years of tractors, GRAVELY and otherwise, and advertized as 18hp.
In fact, there is nothing in those parts breakdowns to imply that any M18 produced measurably more or less power than any other M18.
And just to be clear, for those who will say that the carb is different - carburators cannot dictate horsepower, they can only limit max rpm by limiting max air flow - not a factor on a governed engine. The throttle bore of all the M18 and M20 carbs are the same - so their cfm is the same.
Cam lift and timing, ignition timing, valve size and compression ratio are what control the production of hp and torque in an engine - all of these elements appear to be the same on all M18 engines.
And now with my governor set at 3550 rpm, I am very happy with my 18 hp.
Again, Richard, great conversion and I'm sure it will serve you well, especially as you know how to treat the PTO clutch with respect.
Those Onan engiens are great - shame they are no longer made.
Sheldon
Thank you for taking the time to share the more technical aspects of this with us. While not a difficult conversion, not something I would likley jump into since I don't have some of the resources you do.
Should my 16G, (18GLX ?) ever need an engine, I will likely go the new engine route. But actually I won't be unhappy if I never need to.
Reading this last night got me thinking more about the debated differences between the M18 supplied on my tractor, marked 16hp, and other M18's, GRAVELY or other wise.
I have a Kohler master parts list for the M18, M20 engines, and after even more review of the parts used on verious spec numbers, there is no doubt in my mind that the M18 on my 16G is every bit the same engine power wise as the same year 18G engine, and many other M18's installed on various other brands and years of tractors, GRAVELY and otherwise, and advertized as 18hp.
In fact, there is nothing in those parts breakdowns to imply that any M18 produced measurably more or less power than any other M18.
And just to be clear, for those who will say that the carb is different - carburators cannot dictate horsepower, they can only limit max rpm by limiting max air flow - not a factor on a governed engine. The throttle bore of all the M18 and M20 carbs are the same - so their cfm is the same.
Cam lift and timing, ignition timing, valve size and compression ratio are what control the production of hp and torque in an engine - all of these elements appear to be the same on all M18 engines.
And now with my governor set at 3550 rpm, I am very happy with my 18 hp.
Again, Richard, great conversion and I'm sure it will serve you well, especially as you know how to treat the PTO clutch with respect.
Those Onan engiens are great - shame they are no longer made.
Sheldon